The two trillion dollar towers of student and auto debt: As Americans are unable to afford homes, many go deep into debt to finance their education and cars.

As Americans continue to see their income lag inflation, many are unable to purchase homes in a market driven by hot money and a crowding out effect brought on by investors.  But people want to spend money, even money they don’t have.  So instead of buying homes, Americans have been on a car buying spree and also going into deep debt for college.  The end result is that we now have two trillion dollar towers of debt.  Student debt outstanding is at $1.36 trillion and auto debt is now over $1.01 trillion.  A large part of the rise in auto debt has come in the form of subprime auto debt.  A car is not an investment.  And with your typical new car costing $30,000 this is no tiny purchase given the median annual household income of $50,000.  So Americans are doing what they do best and that is financing big ticket purchases to grasp at the illusion of being middle class.  Let us look at what has changed in the last decade.

How we now have two trillion dollar debt sectors outside of housing

Go back in time to 2004.  Every segment of non-mortgage debt was well below the $1 trillion mark.  In fact, the numbers were substantially low relative to where we are at today.  For student debt, in 2004 there was “only” $260 billion outstanding and auto debt stood at $720 billion.  At the time this seemed high but over the next 10 years student debt grew by a stunning $1 trillion.

Now, student debt outstanding is at $1.36 trillion and auto debt is at $1.01 trillion:

There are two important things to focus on here.  The growth of auto debt did pause during the Great Recession.  This was not the case for student debt which seemed to accelerate as millions decided to ride out the great crisis by going to college.  Unfortunately many are finding their college degrees are simply not yielding the expected income that they thought they would earn after getting their newly minted diplomas.  This is why we have seen a shift in delinquencies for various loan products.

In 2004 the worst performing loans were with credit cards and “other” kinds of loans.  Today the worst performing non-mortgage debt category is clearly with student loans:

There are a variety of reasons as to why this is much more problematic today:

-1.  The amount outstanding is much higher than before.

-2.  Student debt is at $1.36 trillion.

-3.  There is no bankruptcy exit clause for student loans.

-4.  Student loans are accessible to anyone and there is no clear education on the front-end as to what the true cost of borrowing will be.  And this is for 17 and 18 year old “adults” who are likely making the biggest financial decision of their lives.

-5.  A large portion of auto debt growth has come from subprime loans.

There is no slowing down the student debt juggernaut.  If we continue down this path we are looking at $2 trillion in student debt outstanding by 2020:

If it is bad now, how will it be in the future?  Income growth has to come in a meaningful way to justify current debt loads.  Many are realizing that an expensive college degree is simply not worth it if your first job is in the low-wage sector of our economy.  What this runaway debt expansion in auto loans and student debt suggests is that Americans are borrowing large amounts with the hopes of holding on to the dream of the middle class lifestyle.  In reality, many are just assisting in building the twin trillion dollar towers of debt.  People do realize our last crisis was largely brought on by people and banks taking on too much debt right?